Measuring and Responding to Income Poverty

Ronald Kneebone, Margarita Wilkins

Abstract


This paper discusses and describes measures of poverty and, on the basis of that discussion, proposes a public policy response that more closely and more easily targets income support to where it is most needed and most effective. Our review of poverty measures shows there are many holes that prevent advocates and policy-makers from obtaining a clear picture of who is in poverty and the depth of that poverty. The Market Basket Measure is the most finely tuned to identifying where impoverished families live and that is in large part why it was recently adopted by the federal government to gauge its anti-poverty policies. The government of Alberta, on the other hand, evaluates its policies using a measure of poverty that allows no consideration that costs of living might vary by community. Social assistance is the main policy instrument through which the federal and provincial governments provide assistance to people in need. We show that the growing emphasis of increasing social-assistance support via child benefits provides no increase in support in what has been for some time the majority of social-assistance cases. What’s more, despite a great deal of evidence that the cost of meeting basic needs varies widely by community, the amount of assistance provided is the same regardless of where one lives in the province. We propose a modification to how social assistance is provided that makes allowances for the fact poverty is deeper in some parts of the province than others and that provides support to individuals and families whether or not they have children. Our proposal is superior to rent control as a means of dealing with falling housing affordability, removes barriers to people receiving social assistance from moving to seek employment, and has features similar to a guaranteed basic income. It is also inexpensive. We estimate the cost of our proposal to be equivalent to less than one per cent of the provincial health-care budget.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Armitage, A. (2003) Social Welfare in Canada, Toronto: Oxford University Press.

Atkinson, A.B., L. Rainwater and T. M. Smeeding (1995), Income Distribution in OECD Countries, OECD Social Policy Studies, No. 18, Paris.

Aldridge, H. (2017), “How do we Measure Poverty?” Backgrounder, Maytree Foundation, May.

Boychuk, G. (2006) “Slouching Toward the Bottom? Provincial Social Assistance Provision in Canada, 1980-2000” in Kathryn Harrison (editor) Racing to the Bottom? Provincial Interdependence in the Canadian Federation, UBC Press.

Briggs, A. and C. Lee (2012) “Poverty Costs: An Economic Case for a Preventative Poverty Reduction Strategy in Alberta,” Vibrant Communities Calgary http://vibrantcalgary.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/poverty-costs_feb06-2012.pdf

Cobham, A. and A. Sumner (2013) “Is it All About the Tails? The Palma Measure of Income Inequality,” Center for Global Development, Working Paper 343, September.

Corak, M. (2016), “’Inequality is the Root of Social Evil,’ or Maybe Not? Two Stories about Inequality and Public Policy,” Canadian Public Policy, Volume 42, Issue 4, December.

Government of Alberta (2018), Annual Report, Community and Social Services. https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/20f7bf5e-3b69-4400-8785-5b195e1491f1/resource/ca6f040b-7cf9-4ad8-a8ca-2b301341f554/download/community-social-services-annual-report-2017-2018.pdf

Diamond, R., T. McQuade, and F. Qian, (2018) “The Effects of Rent Control Expansion on Tenants, Landlords, and Inequality: Evidence from San Francisco,” NBER Working Paper No. 24181, January.

Ference & Company Consulting Ltd. (nd), “Tackling Poverty Together,” https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/poverty-reduction/reports/tackling-poverty-together.html#h2.5

Finn, Dan & Goodship, Jo. (2014). Take-up of benefits and poverty: an evidence and policy review. JRF/CESI Report.

Goering, P., S. Veldhuizen, A. Watson, C. Adair, B. Kopp, E. Latimer, G. Nelson, E. MacNaughton, D. Streiner and T. Aubry (2014). National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report. Calgary, AB: Mental Health Commission of Canada.

Government of Alberta (2018), Fiscal Plan, Budget 2018.

Hatfield, M., W. Pyper, and B. Gustajtis, (2010), “First Comprehensive Review of the Market Based Measure of Low Income: Final Report,” Human Resources and Skills Development Canada.

Hicks, P. (2018), “Measuring Poverty? Let’s Get Empirical,” Policy Options, January.

HRSDC (2010), “First Comprehensive Review of the Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Final Report,” June. http://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2011/rhdcc-hrsdc/HS28-178-2010-eng.pdf

Kneebone, R. and M. Wilkins (2016a), “Shrinking the Need for Homeless Shelter Spaces,” SPP Research Papers, School of Public Policy, Volume 9, Issue 21, May.

Kneebone, R. and M. Wilkins (2016b), “The Very Poor and the Affordability of Housing,” SPP Research Papers, School of Public Policy, Volume 9, Issue 27, September.

Macdonald, D. (2018), “Born to Win: Wealth Concentration in Canada since 1999,” Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives https://www.policyalternatives.ca/sites/default/files/uploads/publications/National%20Office/2018/07/Born%20to%20Win.pdf

Murphy, B., X. Zhang, and C. Dionne (2012), “Low Income in Canada: a Multi-line and Multi-index Perspective,” Income Research Paper Series, Income Statistics Division, Statistics Canada.

Noel, A. (2017), “How do We Measure Poverty?,” Policy Options, November. http://policyoptions.irpp.org/magazines/november-2017/how-do-we-measure-poverty/

Omar, Heba (2018), “Equivalence Scales and Child Poverty: A Closer Look at Different Family Types across Developed Countries,” LIS Newsletter, Issue No. 5 (March). http://www.lisdatacenter.org/wp-content/uploads/files/nl-2018-5.pdf

Robson, J. and P. Nares (eds) (2006), “Wealth and Well-Being Ownership and Opportunity: New Directions in Social Policy for Canada,” Social Enterprise and Development Innovations.

Robson, J. (2008), “Wealth, Low-Wage Work and Welfare: The Unintended Consequences of Provincial Needs-Tests.” Toronto, Ontario: Social and Enterprise Development Innovations.

Schanzenback, D., R. Nunn, L. Bauer, and M. Mumford (2016). “Where does all the Money Go: Shifts in Household Spending over the Past 30 Years.” http://www.hamiltonproject.org/papers/where_does_all_the_money_go_shifts_in_household_spending_over_the_past_30_y

Social Metrics Commission (2018). A New Measure of Poverty for the UK.

Stapleton, J. (2009), Why Don’t We Want the Poor to Won Anything?” Metcalfe Foundation.

The Council on Aging (2018), “Toward a ‘New Canada Poverty Line’ (NCPL): Input to the Canadian Poverty Reduction Strategy,” https://coaottawa.ca/wp-content/uploads/documents/Toward-a-Poverty-Line-22APRIL2018.pdf

Tweddle, A., K. Battle, and S. Tjorman (2017). “Welfare in Canada, 2016.” Canada Social Report, The Caledon Institute of Social Policy. https://maytree.com/wp-content/uploads/Welfare_in_Canada_2016.pdf

Wilkins, M. and R. Kneebone (2018a), “The Energy Boom and Income Growth,” Social Policy Trends, School of Public Policy, January.

Wilkins, M. and R. Kneebone (2018b), “Social Assistance Caseloads in Alberta by Family Composition,” Social Policy Trends, School of Public Policy, April.

Wilkinson, Richard G. (2005). The impact of inequality: how to make sick societies healthier. London: Routledge

Zhang, X. (2010), “Low Income Measurement in Canada: What Do Different Lines and Indexes Tell Us?” Income Research Paper Series, Statistics Canada. http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/75f0002m/75f0002m2010003-eng.pdf




DOI: https://doi.org/10.11575/sppp.v12i0.58433

DOI (PDF): https://doi.org/10.11575/sppp.v12i0.58433.g51702

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.